Jeremy and Cathy are high school sweethearts, and they have been dating for many years. Everyone, including Jeremy's mother, wants him to put a ring on Cathy's finger, but he doesn't feel like he and Cathy are soulmates.
He wants to experience life, and ultimately be with someone he can connect with deeply. There is immense pressure on him, and being 35 years old is not helping either.
When he meets Paula he realizes that there is much more to life than he thought, and how amazing and fulfilling love can be. Paula though comes with her own baggage.
Will he settle for the sake of his long-term girlfriend? Or will he take the risk to be happy?